Why model hailstone trajectories, not just thunderstorm counts?
Show answer & explanation
Answer: Stones change along paths
Storm names predict size — No. A storm label is much too coarse to predict hail size. Two storms with similar names or categories can have different updrafts, water content and melting paths. The useful quantity is what the stone experiences while it is carried, grows and falls.
Radar sees every stone — Not quite. Radar is powerful, but it does not perfectly see every hailstone and its whole growth history. Forecasting still needs physical models of air currents, temperature, water and particle paths. That is why NSSL describes models of entire hailstorms, not just radar labels.
Stones change along paths ✓ — Correct. Hail size is shaped by a moving path through updrafts, cold growth zones and warmer falling air. The Nature study used hailstone trajectory simulations, and NSSL also computes projected hailstone trajectories. Counting thunderstorms alone misses whether stones grow, melt or get carried out of the best growth zone.
More Weather & Climate questions
- Why can a small shift toward larger hail raise damage so much?
- Why do tropical hailstorms produce smaller hail than mid-latitude ones?
- Hail has clear and cloudy bands. Why not just 'up-down elevator rides'?
- Why is the coldest storm top not the best place for hail to grow?
- Why do supercells make 5-cm hail when ordinary storms usually cannot?
- Why can small hail decline while large hail becomes more common?
